Monsters of the Mogollon Rim

    What do goatmen, turpentine, cryptid festivals and cursed gold have in common?

    Listen to the episode

    Episode Summary

    In this uproarious episode of *Rainy Day Rabbit Holes*, hosts Shea and Jody embark on a wild adventure through the sunburnt landscapes and cryptic lore of Arizona, where goatmen, turpentine, cryptid festivals, and the mysterious allure of cursed gold collide in an unforgettable tapestry of storytelling. With a blend of humor and curiosity, the duo invites listeners to unravel the eccentric tales that define the Southwestern state’s folklore, starting with the infamous Mogollon Monster.

    As the episode unfolds, Shea and Jody take you deep into the heart of the Arizona wilderness, where the Mogollon Monster, a creature reminiscent of Bigfoot, has inspired both terror and intrigue among locals for decades. With bloodcurdling screams echoing through the night, tales of this elusive beast become a thrilling backdrop against which the hosts explore the strange and sensational, including the absurd legend of the Goatman. These half-goat, half-human beings are said to roam the deserts, and the duo hilariously speculates on the implications of a romantic entanglement between a drunken prospector and a Goatwoman. Could this peculiar love story hold the key to understanding Arizona’s cryptid folklore?

    Listeners will be captivated by Shea and Jody's exploration of the bizarre connections between these legends and Arizona’s unique history. The discussion meanders through the state’s rich tapestry of mining history, where turpentine and gold became the lifeblood of towns, and where the scent of pine mingled with the whispers of ghost stories. They delve into the lore of cursed gold, recounting the tales of miners who sought fortune only to find themselves ensnared by supernatural forces. What happens when ambition meets the unknown? The answers lie within the rabbit holes of Arizona’s past.

    This episode is not just about the myths themselves; it’s an invitation to consider broader themes of love, ambition, and the human propensity for storytelling. Shea and Jody challenge listeners to ponder whether these cryptids are mere figments of imagination or if they reveal something deeper about our desire to connect with the mysteries of the world around us.

    Join Shea and Jody on this entertaining journey through Arizona’s most outlandish legends, as they navigate a world where the ordinary meets the extraordinary. With their signature style, they promise laughter, thought-provoking insights, and a healthy dose of skepticism about the supernatural. Tune in to this episode of *Rainy Day Rabbit Holes* and prepare to have your curiosity piqued as you uncover the strange and wonderful nexus of goatmen, cryptids, and the haunted tales of the Arizona desert.

    What do goatmen, turpentine, cryptid festivals, and cursed gold have in common? Apparently, Arizona — and we are here for it!


    In this hilarious, unhinged episode of Rainy Day Rabbit Holes, Shea and Jody dive deep into the lore of Arizona’s Mogollon Monster and the absurd legend of the Goatman.


    From bloodcurdling screams in the desert night to drunken prospectors falling in love with half-goat ladies, this episode is packed with bizarre stories, laughs, and wild theories.


    Could Zeke’s forbidden romance have birthed Arizona’s Bigfoot? Could goats really be the secret architects of desert cryptids?

    May 8, 2025

    Episode Gallery

    Goatmen, Gold & the Mogollon Monster

    Goatmen, Gold & the Mogollon Monster

    Chapters

    0:00
    Welcome to Rainy Day Rabbit Holes
    1:00
    Mogollon Monster Mispronunciation Mayhem
    7:30
    The Hairy Enigma of Arizona’s Mogollon Rim
    15:00
    Cryptid Traits: Screams, Scents, and Stones
    28:00
    The Goatman’s Curse and Drunken Love Story
    55:00
    Solving Arizona’s Cryptid Genealogy
    00:00
    The Goatman Festival and Final Theories

    Sources and Links

    Episode Location

    Mogollon Rim Drive, Lakeside, Arizona 85929, United States

    Loading map...

    Location of the Monsters of the Mogollon Rim

    Lat: 34.158626Lng: -110.010704

    Frequently Asked Questions